Intermediatemolecular biology

Haplodiploidy and the Evolution of Eusociality

Overview

Honeybee workers sacrifice their own reproduction to raise the queen's offspring. Haplodiploidy — where males are haploid and females diploid — makes full sisters share 75% of their genes, and W.D. Hamilton's kin selection theory explains how this favors altruism.

Learning objectives

  • Explain haplodiploid sex determination
  • Calculate relatedness coefficients
  • State Hamilton's rule
  • Evaluate kin selection vs. alternatives

How haplodiploidy works

The queen stores sperm and controls fertilization. Fertilized eggs (diploid) become females — workers or queens depending on larval diet (royal jelly). Unfertilized eggs (haploid) become drones, which have no father and make identical sperm by mitosis.

Key idea

Fertilized → female (2n). Unfertilized → male (n). Drones have no father; their sperm are clones.

The 75% relatedness asymmetry

Full sisters share their father's entire genome (he is haploid) plus half their mother's: 50% + 25% = 75%. A female is related to her own offspring by only 50%. So a worker propagates more of her genes by raising sisters than by reproducing herself.

Exam tip

Sister–sister: 0.75. Mother–daughter: 0.50. This asymmetry is the engine of the kin-selection argument.

Hamilton's rule

Altruism evolves when rB > C: relatedness × benefit to recipient exceeds cost to actor. Haplodiploidy inflates r between sisters, making worker altruism profitable in genetic currency.

Formula

rB > C — Hamilton's rule. r = relatedness, B = benefit, C = cost.

Complications and alternatives

Many eusocial species are diploid (termites, naked mole-rats), and many haplodiploid species are solitary — so haplodiploidy helps but is neither necessary nor sufficient. Monogamy (high relatedness) and ecological benefits of group living also matter.

Watch out

Exams love the nuance: haplodiploidy predisposes to eusociality but does not guarantee it.

Caste determination

All female larvae are genetically identical; diet decides fate. Royal jelly triggers queen development via epigenetic changes (DNA methylation) — a striking case of nutrition rewriting development.

Exam tip

Queen vs. worker is environmental (diet/epigenetics), not genetic — same genome, different destiny.

Key points

  • Drones are haploid males
  • Sisters share 75% of genes
  • Hamilton's rule: rB > C
  • Caste is diet-determined
  • Haplodiploidy helps but isn't required for eusociality

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Worker bees are a separate genetic caste.

✓ Truth: Workers and queens are genetically identical females; larval diet and epigenetics determine caste.

✗ Myth: Haplodiploidy alone explains eusociality.

✓ Truth: Diploid termites and mole-rats are eusocial too — monogamy and ecology matter as much.

Practice questions

Q1. A honeybee drone develops from:
  1. An unfertilized haploid egg
  2. A fertilized diploid egg
  3. A worker-laid diploid egg
  4. A queen's somatic cell
Answer: A.

Drones are haploid males from unfertilized eggs; they have no father.

Q2. According to Hamilton's rule, worker altruism is favored when:
  1. rB > C
  2. B > rC
  3. C > rB
  4. r = 1
Answer: A.

Relatedness times benefit must exceed the cost to the altruist.

Q3. Royal jelly's role in caste determination is best described as:
  1. An environmental/epigenetic trigger
  2. A mutagen
  3. A sex chromosome
  4. An antibiotic
Answer: A.

Nutrition triggers epigenetic changes (including DNA methylation) that direct queen development.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

Why are full sisters in honeybees related by 0.75?

Their haploid father contributes an identical genome to every daughter (50%), and they share half their mother's genome on average (25%), totaling 75% — more than the 50% between mother and daughter.

State Hamilton's rule and explain its terms.

rB > C: an altruistic act evolves when relatedness (r) times the benefit to the recipient (B) exceeds the reproductive cost to the actor (C).

What determines whether a female larva becomes a queen or worker?

Diet: larvae fed royal jelly throughout development become queens; others become workers. The difference is epigenetic, not genetic.