Intermediateexam strategy
Pedigree Solving Strategy: Crack Any Family Tree
Learning objectives
- Determine autosomal vs X-linked and dominant vs recessive inheritance from any pedigree.
- Assign genotypes to individuals systematically using the process of elimination.
- Calculate recurrence probabilities for unborn children.
- Recognize the signature patterns of each inheritance mode instantly.
Step 1: Dominant or Recessive?
Start with the dominant/recessive question — it constrains everything else. The golden rule: if two unaffected parents have an affected child, the trait must be recessive (both parents were hidden carriers). Conversely, if an affected child has two unaffected parents, dominant inheritance is impossible. If every affected individual has at least one affected parent, dominant inheritance is likely. A second clue: recessive traits often skip generations and appear in children of unaffected parents, while dominant traits appear in every generation. Make this determination first and write it down — most pedigree errors come from carrying two competing hypotheses instead of committing to the evidence. Draw the pedigree yourself from a word description when given one; the act of drawing forces you to process every relationship stated.
Step 2: Autosomal or X-Linked?
With dominance settled, test the chromosome. For X-linked recessive: affected fathers pass the trait to all daughters (who become at least carriers) but to no sons — so an affected father with an unaffected daughter rules out X-linked recessive only if she shows no carrier signs; more usefully, an affected daughter must have an affected father, so an affected daughter with a normal father rules out X-linked recessive. For X-linked dominant: affected fathers pass to all daughters, and the trait never passes father-to-son. Autosomal patterns show roughly equal sex distribution and allow father-to-son transmission. Apply these as elimination tests: each observation that contradicts a mode crosses it off. Often only one mode survives. When stuck between two modes, test each against every individual systematically rather than trusting gut feeling; pedigrees reward methodical elimination.
Dominant/recessive first (unaffected parents + affected child = recessive), then autosomal/X-linked via father-daughter and father-son transmission tests. Commit to what survives elimination.
Step 3: Assign Genotypes Systematically
Once the mode is fixed, assign genotypes starting from the most constrained individuals. Affected individuals in recessive traits are homozygous recessive — write it in. Their parents must each carry one copy. Unaffected individuals with affected children must be carriers (recessive) or heterozygous (dominant). Work outward from these anchors, using each mating's offspring to constrain the parents. For individuals whose genotype remains ambiguous (e.g., a normal child of a carrier × normal mating), express it as a probability: 2/3 carrier among normal offspring of two carriers. Write probabilities as fractions beside the symbols — pedigree probability questions almost always hinge on these conditional assignments. Keep a reference card of the classic mode signatures and consult it during practice until the patterns become automatic.
Step 4: Compute the Asked Probability
Read the question's exact ask before calculating. 'What is the probability the next child is affected?' combines the parents' carrier probabilities with the cross outcome: for two carriers in a recessive trait, 1/4 per child. 'Given the child is unaffected, what is the probability it is a carrier?' is conditional — among the 3/4 unaffected offspring of Aa × Aa, 2/3 are carriers. Multiply independent probabilities along a lineage (product rule) and add mutually exclusive paths (sum rule). A frequent trap: using 1/2 as a carrier's probability when the question conditions on the person being unaffected — always condition first, then compute. Draw the pedigree yourself from a word description when given one; the act of drawing forces you to process every relationship stated.
'Unaffected child of two carriers' means the 1/4 affected outcome is excluded — the carrier probability among the rest is 2/3, not 1/2. Forgetting to condition is the top pedigree probability error.
Key points
- Determine dominant/recessive first: unaffected parents with an affected child means recessive.
- Test autosomal vs X-linked with father-daughter and father-son transmission observations.
- Assign genotypes from the most constrained individuals outward; write conditional probabilities as fractions.
- Condition on given information (e.g., unaffected status) before computing probabilities.
- Combine lineage probabilities with the product rule and alternative paths with the sum rule.
Common misconceptions
✓ Truth: It suggests X-linked recessive but doesn't prove it — small pedigrees can skew by chance. Use transmission tests (affected daughters, father-to-son) for proof, not just counts.
✓ Truth: It strongly suggests recessive, but dominant traits with incomplete penetrance can also appear to skip. Look for the unaffected-parents-affected-child case as the definitive test.
Frequently asked questions
How do I spot autosomal dominant quickly?
Look for affected individuals in every generation, roughly equal numbers of affected males and females, and father-to-son transmission. An affected child always having an affected parent is the hallmark.
What does a double line between parents mean?
Consanguinity — the parents are related, typically cousins. It raises the probability of homozygous recessive children and is a hint toward recessive inheritance.
Can a pedigree fit two inheritance modes?
Yes, small pedigrees are sometimes ambiguous. If so, state your assumption explicitly and solve under it — examiners accept well-reasoned answers that declare assumptions, and many questions are designed with a single best fit.