Intermediatepopulation

Twin Studies

Overview

Twin studies compare monozygotic (identical, 100% genes) and dizygotic (fraternal, ~50%) twins: greater MZ similarity implies genetic influence. Falconer's formula (h^2 = 2*(rMZ - rDZ)) estimates heritability. Findings: schizophrenia ~0.8, height ~0.8-0.9, personality ~0.4-0.5, shared environment often near zero for adult personality. Adoption and separated-twin studies strengthen causal inference.

Learning objectives

  • Explain the MZ/DZ logic
  • Apply Falconer's formula
  • Summarize major findings
  • Critique assumptions and limits

The design

MZ twins: one zygote, ~100% shared genes. DZ twins: two zygotes, ~50% like siblings. Both share womb, family, cohort: the comparison isolates genetic sharing. rMZ > rDZ -> genetic influence; rMZ ~ rDZ -> shared environment dominates.

The contrast is the experiment

Genetic sharing varies while family environment is matched: nature's controlled trial.

Falconer's formula

h^2 = 2(rMZ - rDZ). Example: schizophrenia rMZ ~ 0.5, rDZ ~ 0.2 -> h^2 ~ 0.6 (liability scale ~0.8). Shared environment c^2 = 2rDZ - rMZ; non-shared e^2 = 1 - rMZ. Simple, powerful, assumption-laden.

ACE model

A (additive genes) + C (shared environment) + E (non-shared): the variance decomposition twins enable.

Landmark findings

Schizophrenia/bipolar: h^2 ~ 0.7-0.8. Height: ~0.8-0.9. Big Five personality: ~0.4-0.5, mostly non-shared environment. IQ: rises with age (~0.2 childhood -> ~0.8 adulthood). Minnesota separated-twin studies found striking MZ similarities reared apart.

Heritability ≠ determinism

Schizophrenia h^2 ~ 0.8 yet most high-risk individuals never develop it: risk, not fate.

Criticisms

Equal-environment assumption (MZ treated more alike?), chorionicity differences (MZ twins sharing placentas), assortative mating inflating DZ similarity, generalizability (twins aren't singletons), and the missing-GWAS gap: twin h^2 exceeds SNP h^2, implicating rare variants and non-additive effects.

Missing heritability debate

Twin estimates exceed molecular ones: the field's central puzzle, partly resolving via rare variants.

Key points

  • MZ (100% genes) vs DZ (~50%): rMZ > rDZ implies genetic influence
  • Falconer's h^2 = 2*(rMZ - rDZ); ACE decomposition
  • Findings: schizophrenia/height ~0.8, personality ~0.4-0.5
  • Assumptions (equal environments) and missing heritability are key caveats

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Twin studies prove traits are genetic.

✓ Truth: They estimate variance components under assumptions; molecular studies must identify actual variants.

✗ Myth: Identical twins are 100% identical.

✓ Truth: They differ in somatic mutations, epigenetics, and X-inactivation: 'identical' is approximate.

Practice questions

Q1. If rMZ = 0.8 and rDZ = 0.5 for a trait, Falconer's h^2 is
  1. 0.3
  2. 0.6
  3. 0.8
  4. 1.0
Answer: B.

Falconer's formula gives h² = 2 × (rMZ − rDZ) = 2 × (0.8 − 0.5) = 0.6.

Q2. Greater MZ than DZ similarity suggests
  1. Shared environment only
  2. Genetic influence
  3. Nothing
  4. Measurement error
Answer: B.

The design isolates genetic sharing as the difference.

Q3. A common criticism of twin studies is
  1. Too many twins
  2. The equal-environment assumption may fail
  3. Genes don't exist
  4. Math errors
Answer: B.

If MZ pairs share more similar environments, h^2 is overestimated.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

Why does IQ heritability rise with age?

Active rGE: genotypes increasingly select environments (reading, peers), amplifying genetic differences.

What did separated-twin studies show?

MZ reared apart remain strikingly similar (Minnesota study): genes matter even across households.

Do twins generalize to singletons?

Mostly yes for heritability, but twin-specific prenatal factors (shared womb, lower birth weight) add caveats.