Intermediatepopulation

Stabilizing Selection

Overview

Stabilizing selection favors intermediate phenotypes and selects against both extremes, narrowing the trait distribution without shifting its mean. Human birth weight (too small: prematurity risks; too large: delivery risks), clutch size in birds (too few: low fecundity; too many: starvation), and many physiological optima show this pattern. It is probably the commonest mode of selection, quietly maintaining adapted traits.

Learning objectives

  • Define stabilizing selection
  • Explain the birth-weight example
  • Describe effects on mean and variance
  • Give clutch-size and other examples

Trimming the tails

When intermediates have highest fitness, both extremes are pruned each generation: the mean stays put while variance shrinks. Unlike directional selection, stabilizing selection preserves the status quo; unlike disruptive, it does not split the population. Most traits under long-term adaptation sit under stabilizing selection.

Mean fixed, variance reduced

The bell curve gets narrower but does not move.

Human birth weight

Classic data (Karn & Penrose): very light babies face prematurity and infection risks; very heavy babies face obstructed labor. Intermediate weights (~3-4 kg historically) survived best. Modern medicine has relaxed this selection, and mean birth weights have risen slightly.

Medicine relaxes selection

Cesarean delivery and neonatal care now rescue extremes that selection once removed.

Clutch size and other optima

Lack's principle: birds lay the clutch size maximizing surviving offspring, fewer eggs waste opportunity, more starve. Stabilizing selection tunes it. Similar optima: flower morphology matching pollinators, enzyme temperature optima, blood pH regulation.

Optima are everywhere

Physiology is largely the study of traits under stabilizing selection.

Maintaining variation paradox

If extremes are always pruned, why does variation persist? Mutation replenishes it, environments fluctuate (shifting the optimum), and many traits are polygenic with tiny per-locus effects that selection barely sees. Stabilizing selection maintains the mean, not uniformity.

Stabilizing != no evolution

The optimum can move; stabilizing selection then becomes directional until the new optimum is reached.

Key points

  • Stabilizing selection favors intermediates, trimming both extremes
  • Mean unchanged, variance reduced
  • Birth weight and clutch size are classic examples
  • Probably the commonest selection mode; maintains adapted traits

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Stabilizing selection increases variation.

✓ Truth: It reduces variance by pruning extremes; mutation and fluctuating optima replenish variation.

✗ Myth: Stabilizing selection stops evolution.

✓ Truth: It maintains current adaptation but the optimum can shift, converting it to directional selection.

Practice questions

Q1. Stabilizing selection
  1. Shifts the mean
  2. Favors intermediates, reducing variance
  3. Favors both extremes
  4. Has no effect
Answer: B.

Intermediates have highest fitness; extremes are selected against.

Q2. Human birth weight shows stabilizing selection because
  1. Only average babies are born
  2. Both very light and very heavy babies had lower survival
  3. Doctors prefer it
  4. It is not heritable
Answer: B.

Prematurity risks at the low end and delivery risks at the high end both reduced fitness.

Q3. Under stabilizing selection, the trait mean over generations
  1. Increases
  2. Decreases
  3. Stays approximately constant
  4. Splits in two
Answer: C.

Selection holds the mean at the optimum while narrowing variation.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

Why does birth-weight selection still allow variation?

Mutation, environmental variation, and relaxed modern selection maintain the spread; selection trims but never zeroes variance.

What is Lack's clutch-size principle?

Birds evolve the clutch size maximizing surviving young, balancing egg number against provisioning capacity.

How does stabilizing selection differ from purifying selection?

Purifying selection removes deleterious alleles at the molecular level; stabilizing selection is the phenotypic-level analogue favoring intermediate trait values.