Intermediatepopulation

Sexual Selection

Overview

Sexual selection arises from competition for mates and mate choice, producing extravagant traits (peacock tails, deer antlers) that may reduce survival but increase reproductive success. It has two modes: intrasexual competition (male-male combat) and intersexual choice (female preference). Runaway and good-genes models explain how preferences and ornaments coevolve.

Learning objectives

  • Define sexual selection and its two modes
  • Explain intrasexual competition vs intersexual choice
  • Describe runaway and good-genes models
  • Discuss costs and honest signaling

Darwin's second mechanism

Natural selection could not explain the peacock's tail: it hinders flight and attracts predators. Darwin proposed sexual selection: traits evolve because they win mates, even at survival cost. Total fitness = survival x mating success; ornaments trade the first for the second.

Mating success is a fitness component

A trait that halves survival but triples matings still spreads.

Combat vs choice

Intrasexual selection: males fight for access (antlers, elephant seal bulk, beetle horns); winners sire disproportionately. Intersexual selection: choosers (usually females, who invest more) pick mates by ornaments, dances, or gifts (bowerbird bowers, widowbird tails). Both generate rapid, dramatic evolution.

Anisogamy drives the asymmetry

Costly eggs vs cheap sperm make females choosy and males competitive in most systems; sex-role-reversed species (phalaropes) flip the pattern.

Why preferences evolve

Fisherian runaway: preference and ornament genes become linked; sexy sons inherit both, driving exponential exaggeration until survival costs halt it. Good genes: ornaments honestly signal health (bright plumage = parasite resistance, Hamilton-Zuk). Sensory bias: preferences pre-exist for other reasons and males exploit them.

Handicap principle

Zahavi argued only costly signals are honest: a sick peacock cannot afford a magnificent tail.

Experimental proof

Andersson's widowbird experiment: lengthening males' tails (glued extensions) quadrupled mating success; shortening reduced it. Peahens prefer males with more eyespots. These manipulations prove female choice, not correlated vigor, drives ornament evolution.

Manipulation experiments decide

Altering the ornament alone and measuring mating success isolates sexual selection from confounds.

Key points

  • Sexual selection = competition for mates + mate choice
  • Intrasexual (combat) and intersexual (choice) are the two modes
  • Runaway, good-genes, and handicap models explain ornament-preference coevolution
  • Ornaments trade survival for reproductive success

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Sexual selection is separate from natural selection.

✓ Truth: Modern theory treats it as a component of natural selection: differential reproductive success, whatever its cause.

✗ Myth: Only males evolve ornaments.

✓ Truth: Whichever sex competes evolves them; in sex-role-reversed species (jacanas, phalaropes), females are the ornamented competitors.

Practice questions

Q1. Sexual selection differs from viability selection in that it acts on
  1. Survival
  2. Mating/reproductive success
  3. Mutation rate
  4. Migration
Answer: B.

It favors traits that win mates, even at survival cost.

Q2. Fisherian runaway requires genetic linkage between
  1. Two ornaments
  2. Preference genes and ornament genes
  3. Mitochondria
  4. Sex chromosomes
Answer: B.

Choosy females' sons inherit both the ornament and the preference, fueling coevolution.

Q3. In most species females are choosier because
  1. They are larger
  2. Anisogamy: eggs cost more than sperm
  3. They are weaker
  4. Males choose first
Answer: B.

Greater per-offspring investment makes mate quality matter more to females.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

What did Andersson's widowbird experiment show?

Tail length directly caused mating success: lengthened tails won, shortened tails lost, proving female choice.

Why don't ornaments grow infinitely?

Survival costs eventually balance mating benefits (plus genetic constraints); runaway halts at the cost-benefit equilibrium.

How does the handicap principle ensure honesty?

Only genuinely healthy males can afford extravagant ornaments, so the signal reliably indicates quality.