Foundationsmendelian

Mendel's Law of Segregation

Overview

Mendel's first law states that every individual carries two alleles for each gene, and these alleles segregate (separate) during gamete formation so that each gamete receives only one allele. Fertilization then restores the pair. This explains why two heterozygous (Aa) parents produce offspring in a 1 AA : 2 Aa : 1 aa genotypic ratio, and why recessive traits hidden in the F1 reappear in the F2.

Learning objectives

  • State the law of segregation in your own words
  • Connect segregation to meiosis (anaphase I)
  • Predict gamete genotypes from a parent's genotype
  • Explain the 1:2:1 genotypic ratio of an Aa x Aa cross

More worked crosses

Aa x Aa (monohybrid)

Two heterozygous pea plants crossed; gametes A/a x A/a.

Result: Offspring 1 AA : 2 Aa : 1 aa; 3 dominant : 1 recessive phenotype.

Aa x aa (test cross)

Heterozygote crossed to homozygous recessive.

Result: Offspring 1 Aa : 1 aa; 1 dominant : 1 recessive phenotype.

The law stated

During gamete formation, the two alleles for a gene separate so that each gamete carries exactly one allele. A heterozygous Aa parent therefore produces A-bearing and a-bearing gametes in equal numbers. This was Mendel's explanation for the 3:1 F2 ratio: random union of these gametes gives AA, Aa, aA, and aa zygotes, i.e., 1:2:1 by genotype and 3:1 by phenotype when A is dominant.

One allele per gamete

Segregation is why a carrier (Aa) parent has a 50% chance of passing the a allele to each child, independent of previous children.

The chromosomal basis: meiosis

Mendel knew nothing of chromosomes, but the law maps perfectly onto meiosis I. Homologous chromosomes (one carrying A, the other a) separate during anaphase I, so each daughter cell gets one homolog. Meiosis II then separates sister chromatids. The physical separation of homologs IS segregation at the molecular level.

Sutton and Boveri

Around 1902, Sutton and Boveri independently proposed that Mendel's factors reside on chromosomes, giving the law a physical mechanism.

Test crosses confirm segregation

Crossing a dominant-phenotype plant of unknown genotype to a homozygous recessive (Aa x aa or AA x aa) tests the law's prediction. If the unknown parent is Aa, offspring are 1:1 dominant:recessive; if AA, all offspring show the dominant trait. Mendel used such crosses to verify that F2 dominant plants were a mix of AA and Aa in a 1:2 ratio.

F2 dominant plants are 1/3 AA and 2/3 Aa

Selfing each F2 dominant plant reveals its genotype: AA plants breed true, Aa plants produce 3:1 offspring.

When the law appears to fail

Segregation holds for nuclear genes in diploid organisms, but apparent exceptions exist: meiotic drive (selfish alleles biasing transmission above 50%), gene conversion, and mitochondrial inheritance (no pairing/segregation of alleles). These are genuine biological phenomena layered on top of the law, not refutations of it.

Applies to diploid nuclear genes

Segregation describes alleles on homologous chromosomes. Haploid organisms, organelle genomes, and polyploids need modified expectations.

Key points

  • Each diploid individual carries two alleles per gene; gametes carry one
  • Homologous chromosomes separate in anaphase I of meiosis, the physical basis of segregation
  • Aa x Aa gives 1 AA : 2 Aa : 1 aa genotypes and 3:1 phenotypes
  • Test crosses (x aa) reveal whether a dominant phenotype is AA or Aa

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Segregation means each child gets one allele from each parent mixed together.

✓ Truth: Segregation happens during gamete formation in the parent: the parent's own two alleles separate into different gametes. Fertilization then combines one gamete from each parent.

✗ Myth: The law of segregation and independent assortment are the same thing.

✓ Truth: Segregation concerns the two alleles of ONE gene separating. Independent assortment concerns alleles of DIFFERENT genes sorting independently into gametes.

Practice questions

Q1. According to the law of segregation, a heterozygous Aa individual produces gametes in the ratio
  1. 1 A : 1 a
  2. 3 A : 1 a
  3. 1 AA : 2 Aa : 1 aa
  4. All Aa
Answer: A.

The two alleles separate during gamete formation, so half the gametes carry A and half carry a.

Q2. The physical basis of segregation is the separation of
  1. Sister chromatids in mitosis
  2. Homologous chromosomes in anaphase I of meiosis
  3. Homologous chromosomes in anaphase II
  4. Non-homologous chromosomes in prophase I
Answer: B.

Homologs (one from each parent) part company in anaphase I, sending one allele of each gene to each daughter cell.

Q3. A test cross of an unknown dominant-phenotype plant with aa gives all dominant offspring. The unknown genotype is
  1. Aa
  2. AA
  3. aa
  4. Cannot be determined
Answer: B.

If the parent were Aa, half the offspring would be aa (recessive). All-dominant offspring means the parent contributed only A gametes, so it is AA.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

How does segregation explain carriers of recessive disorders?

A carrier (Aa) is healthy because one working allele suffices, but segregation gives each of their gametes a 50% chance of carrying the a allele, so two carriers face a 25% risk per child.

Does segregation apply to genes on the same chromosome?

Yes, alleles still segregate into gametes, but linked genes tend to travel together, so the gamete combinations are not in equal 1:1:1:1 proportions without crossing over.

What did Mendel call alleles?

He called them 'factors' (Elemente). The term allele came later; Mendel inferred their existence purely from ratios.