Intermediatepopulation

Heterozygote Advantage (Overdominance)

Overview

Heterozygote advantage (overdominance) occurs when the heterozygote has higher fitness than either homozygote, actively maintaining both alleles in a stable polymorphism. The textbook case is sickle-cell: HbAHbS heterozygotes resist malaria better than HbAHbA individuals while avoiding the severe anemia of HbSHbS. The equilibrium frequency depends on the selection coefficients against each homozygote.

Learning objectives

  • Define overdominance
  • Explain the sickle-cell/malaria case quantitatively
  • Derive the stable equilibrium conceptually
  • Give other candidate examples

Sickle cell and malaria

In malarial Africa, HbAHbA individuals suffer malaria mortality; HbSHbS individuals suffer sickle-cell anemia; HbAHbS heterozygotes get substantial malaria protection with only mild red-cell effects. Fitness ranking w_Aa > w_AA > w_aa (or w_Aa > w_aa > w_AA regionally) locks the S allele at 10-20% despite its lethality in homozygotes.

w_Aa highest = stable polymorphism

Whenever the heterozygote is fittest, both alleles persist indefinitely at a calculable equilibrium.

The equilibrium

With selection s1 against AA and s2 against aa, equilibrium p_hat = s2/(s1+s2) (for the A allele). Stronger selection against the S homozygote than against malaria-susceptible normals keeps S the minor allele. This is one of the few cases where we can watch balancing selection maintain a lethal allele.

p_hat = s2/(s1+s2)

The allele less harmed in homozygotes equilibrates at higher frequency.

Other candidates

CFTR heterozygotes may resist cholera/typhoid (debated); Tay-Sachs carriers may resist tuberculosis (debated); MHC loci show extreme polymorphism from pathogen-driven heterozygote advantage (well supported); G6PD deficiency vs malaria parallels sickle cell. Claims require fitness measurements, not just storytelling.

Demand evidence

Many 'heterozygote advantage' stories lack fitness data. Sickle cell and MHC are the gold standards.

Overdominance vs other balancing mechanisms

Balancing selection also includes frequency-dependent selection (rare-allele advantage) and spatial/temporal variation. Overdominance is specifically heterozygote superiority. All maintain polymorphism, but they make different predictions about allele trajectories.

Overdominance is one flavor

Balancing selection is the umbrella; overdominance, frequency-dependence, and fluctuating selection are the mechanisms.

Key points

  • Overdominance: w_Aa > w_AA and w_Aa > w_aa maintains stable polymorphism
  • Sickle-cell heterozygotes resist malaria: the definitive case
  • Equilibrium p_hat = s2/(s1+s2)
  • MHC polymorphism is another strong case; many claims need more evidence

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Heterozygote advantage means heterozygotes are always healthy.

✓ Truth: It means highest RELATIVE fitness, not perfect health: HbAHbS carriers have mild red-cell abnormalities but out-reproduce both homozygotes in malarial zones.

✗ Myth: Sickle-cell allele persists because of drift.

✓ Truth: Drift cannot maintain a lethal allele at 10-20%; only balancing selection explains the observed frequencies.

Practice questions

Q1. Heterozygote advantage maintains polymorphism because
  1. Drift is strong
  2. The heterozygote has the highest fitness
  3. Mutation is high
  4. Migration is high
Answer: B.

Selection actively favors Aa, preventing fixation of either allele.

Q2. The sickle-cell S allele is maintained at high frequency by
  1. Drift
  2. Balancing selection via malaria protection in heterozygotes
  3. Gene flow
  4. Inbreeding
Answer: B.

HbAHbS resists malaria while avoiding severe anemia: classic overdominance.

Q3. At overdominant equilibrium, allele frequency depends on
  1. Mutation rate only
  2. The selection coefficients against each homozygote
  3. Population size only
  4. Nothing; it is random
Answer: B.

p_hat = s2/(s1+s2): the balance of the two homozygote disadvantages.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

Why doesn't the S allele take over completely?

HbSHbS homozygotes have very low fitness, pulling the allele back: the equilibrium balances both homozygote disadvantages.

What happens if malaria is eradicated?

The advantage vanishes; selection then purges S, and frequencies fall over generations (observed where malaria declined).

Is CF heterozygote advantage proven?

No: cholera/typhoid resistance hypotheses lack definitive fitness data; it remains an intriguing but unproven story.