Intermediatepopulation

Hardy-Weinberg Assumptions

Overview

Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium requires five ideal conditions: no mutation, random mating, no gene flow (migration), infinite (very large) population size, and no natural selection. Each assumption maps to an evolutionary force: violating it causes allele frequencies to change. Real populations violate all five to some degree, which is precisely why evolution happens.

Learning objectives

  • List the five H-W assumptions
  • Match each violated assumption to its evolutionary force
  • Explain why each assumption matters mathematically
  • Evaluate how badly real populations violate them

The five conditions

  1. No mutation: no new alleles arise. 2. Random mating: mates pair irrespective of genotype. 3. No gene flow: no migration into/out of the population. 4. Infinite population size: no genetic drift. 5. No selection: all genotypes reproduce equally. Under all five, p and q are frozen forever.
Memorize all five

Mutation, nonrandom mating, gene flow, finite size (drift), selection: each maps to a mechanism of evolution.

What each violation causes

Mutation introduces new alleles (slow). Nonrandom mating (inbreeding, assortative mating) changes genotype frequencies without changing allele frequencies. Gene flow homogenizes populations. Drift randomly shifts frequencies, strongest in small populations. Selection directionally changes frequencies by fitness differences.

Inbreeding is special

Inbreeding changes genotype frequencies (fewer heterozygotes) but NOT allele frequencies, so it violates H-W proportions without being 'evolution' in the allele-frequency sense.

How badly are they violated?

Mutation rates (~10^-8 per base per generation) are negligible short-term. Selection coefficients of 1% reshape frequencies in hundreds of generations. Drift dominates in small populations (endangered species, island colonists). Human populations violate random mating mildly (assortative mating by height, ethnicity) and gene flow massively (global migration).

Assumptions are never perfectly met

H-W is useful precisely because violations are informative, not because nature obeys it.

Testing the assumptions

Chi-square goodness-of-fit of observed vs H-W expected genotypes detects violations in aggregate. Heterozygote deficit suggests inbreeding or population structure (Wahlund effect); excess suggests disassortative mating or heterozygote advantage. Molecular data can separately estimate migration, mutation, and selection.

Heterozygote deficit = inbreeding signal

Fewer Aa than 2pq predicts is the classic signature of nonrandom mating.

Key points

  • Five assumptions: no mutation, random mating, no gene flow, infinite size, no selection
  • Each violation corresponds to an evolutionary force
  • Inbreeding alters genotype frequencies without changing allele frequencies
  • Heterozygote deficit signals inbreeding or population structure

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Violating any assumption means H-W is useless.

✓ Truth: The model's value is as a null hypothesis: the pattern of deviation diagnoses which force is acting.

✗ Myth: Random mating means promiscuity.

✓ Truth: It means mate choice is uncorrelated with genotype at the locus studied; most mating systems approximate it per-locus.

Practice questions

Q1. Which H-W assumption, when violated, changes genotype but NOT allele frequencies?
  1. Selection
  2. Mutation
  3. Nonrandom mating (inbreeding)
  4. Gene flow
Answer: C.

Inbreeding reshuffles alleles into homozygotes without changing p and q.

Q2. A heterozygote deficit relative to H-W expectations suggests
  1. Heterozygote advantage
  2. Inbreeding or population subdivision
  3. High mutation rate
  4. Disassortative mating
Answer: B.

Inbreeding and the Wahlund effect both reduce observed heterozygotes below 2pq.

Q3. The five H-W assumptions include all EXCEPT
  1. No selection
  2. Random mating
  3. No meiosis
  4. Infinite population
Answer: C.

Meiosis is required for the model; the assumptions concern mutation, mating, migration, size, and selection.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Wahlund effect?

Pooling subdivided populations with different allele frequencies creates an apparent heterozygote deficit relative to H-W.

Does natural selection violate H-W?

Yes: differential reproductive success changes allele frequencies, the very definition of evolution.

Why is infinite population size assumed?

To eliminate sampling error (drift); in finite populations, gamete sampling randomly shifts frequencies each generation.