Intermediatepopulation
Disruptive Selection
Overview
Disruptive (diversifying) selection favors both extreme phenotypes over intermediates, potentially splitting a population into two distinct forms. African seedcracker finches evolved large and small beak morphs for different seeds; intermediates, efficient at neither seed type, are selected against. Disruptive selection maintains polymorphism and can initiate speciation when morphs stop interbreeding.
Learning objectives
- Define disruptive selection
- Explain the seedcracker finch case
- Describe effects on distributions (bimodality)
- Connect disruptive selection to speciation
Favoring both extremes
When each extreme exploits a different resource, intermediates fall into a fitness valley: too big for small seeds, too small for big ones. Selection then pushes the population toward two peaks, and the trait distribution becomes bimodal. This is the mirror image of stabilizing selection.
Intermediates lose to specialists on both sides.
Seedcracker finches
Pyrenestes ostrinus has large-billed and small-billed morphs (one gene, two alleles) specialized on hard vs soft sedges. Medium bills crack neither efficiently. The polymorphism is stable because each morph wins in its niche: a textbook case of disruptive selection maintaining discrete forms.
Remarkably, the bill dimorphism maps largely to one genomic region under disruptive selection.
Bimodality and polymorphism
Disruptive selection increases variance and can create bimodal distributions from unimodal ones. Other cases: Batesian mimicry morphs in Papilio butterflies (multiple female forms), host races in apple maggot flies. Assortative mating between morphs amplifies divergence.
Unlike stabilizing/directional modes, disruptive selection expands the trait spread.
A route to speciation
If the two morphs evolve habitat or mating preferences that reduce interbreeding, disruptive selection becomes a speciation engine (sympatric speciation models). Apple maggot flies diverging on apple vs hawthorn hosts may be caught in this act.
Gene flow between morphs must also break down; selection starts the split, isolation finishes it.
Key points
- Disruptive selection favors both extremes over intermediates
- Trait distributions become bimodal; variance increases
- Seedcracker finch beak morphs are the classic case
- Can initiate speciation if morphs stop interbreeding
Common misconceptions
✓ Truth: It creates divergent morphs, but speciation additionally requires reproductive isolation to evolve.
✓ Truth: They are opposites: stabilizing favors the middle, disruptive favors the extremes.
Practice questions
Q1. Disruptive selection
- Favors the average
- Favors both extremes over intermediates
- Is random
- Only affects plants
Extreme phenotypes have highest fitness; intermediates fall in a fitness valley.
Q2. Under disruptive selection, trait variance
- Decreases
- Stays the same
- Increases
- Becomes zero
The population spreads toward two peaks, widening the distribution.
Q3. Disruptive selection can lead to speciation if
- Morphs continue interbreeding freely
- Reproductive isolation evolves between morphs
- Selection stops
- Mutations cease
Divergence needs both selection and reduced gene flow to complete speciation.
Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.
Frequently asked questions
Why are intermediate finch beaks unfit?
They crack neither hard nor soft seeds efficiently: jacks of both trades, masters of none.
How does assortative mating help?
If large-billed birds prefer large-billed mates, gene flow between morphs drops and divergence accelerates.
Give a butterfly example.
Papilio dardanus females mimic several toxic models; intermediates resembling no model are eaten: disruptive selection maintains multiple morphs.