Intermediatepopulation
Directional Selection
Overview
Directional selection favors one extreme phenotype, shifting the population mean over generations: dark peppered moths during industrial soot, antibiotic-resistant bacteria, larger beaks in drought-stricken finches. It reduces variation at the selected loci while driving rapid, observable evolution, and it is the mode behind most adaptations and most human-driven evolution (pesticide and drug resistance).
Learning objectives
- Define directional selection
- Explain the peppered moth case
- Describe antibiotic resistance as directional selection
- Predict effects on trait distributions
Shifting the mean
When fitness increases toward one tail, the trait distribution slides: mean beak depth rose in Galapagos finches after droughts favored large-beak seed crackers (Grant's classic data). Alleles for the favored extreme sweep upward; variation narrows as the favored alleles approach fixation.
Directional selection moves the bell curve sideways while compressing it.
Peppered moths
Industrial melanism: the carbonaria morph of Biston betularia rose from rare to ~90% near industrial Manchester as soot darkened trees and birds preyed on conspicuous light moths; it fell again after clean-air laws. Kettlewell's mark-recapture experiments (1950s) measured the selective predation directly.
Rise and fall of melanism with pollution is among the best-documented natural selection cases.
Antibiotic and pesticide resistance
Antibiotics impose brutal directional selection: susceptible bacteria die, resistant mutants (pre-existing or new) survive and multiply. MRSA, multidrug-resistant TB, and herbicide-resistant weeds are directional selection in action, often via single large-effect alleles sweeping fast.
Sub-lethal dosing kills susceptibles while sparing partial resistants: the perfect recipe for stronger resistance.
Limits and costs
Directional selection depletes the variation it feeds on and often hits trade-offs: large finch beaks crack big seeds but handle small ones poorly. When environments reverse, selection reverses (moth melanism declined post-1956 Clean Air Act).
Allele trajectories follow current fitness; yesterday's adaptation can become today's liability.
Key points
- Directional selection favors one phenotypic extreme, shifting the trait mean
- Peppered moth melanism tracked industrial pollution both ways
- Antibiotic resistance is directional selection on microbes
- It depletes variation and can reverse when environments change
Common misconceptions
✓ Truth: It reduces it: favored alleles sweep toward fixation, compressing the distribution.
✓ Truth: The carbonaria mutation pre-existed; pollution changed SELECTION, not mutation. Selection sorts existing variation.
Practice questions
Q1. Industrial melanism in peppered moths resulted from
- New mutations caused by soot
- Directional selection favoring dark moths on soot-darkened trees
- Drift
- Gene flow
Bird predation selected against conspicuous light moths; the carbonaria allele pre-existed.
Q2. Directional selection typically ___ genetic variation
- Increases
- Reduces
- Does not affect
- Doubles
Favored alleles sweep toward fixation, compressing the trait distribution.
Q3. Incomplete antibiotic courses promote resistance because they
- Kill all bacteria
- Select for partial resistants while killing susceptibles
- Cause mutations directly
- Boost immunity
Sub-lethal exposure is intense directional selection for resistance alleles.
Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.
Frequently asked questions
How fast can directional selection act?
Dramatically: moth melanism shifted in decades; bacterial resistance in years; finch beaks measurably in single droughts.
Why does resistance often involve single genes?
Strong selection favors large-effect alleles that sweep rapidly; polygenic responses are slower and subtler.
What stops directional selection?
Depleted variation, trade-offs (antagonistic pleiotropy), and opposing selection in different environments or life stages.