Intermediatepopulation

Directional Selection

Overview

Directional selection favors one extreme phenotype, shifting the population mean over generations: dark peppered moths during industrial soot, antibiotic-resistant bacteria, larger beaks in drought-stricken finches. It reduces variation at the selected loci while driving rapid, observable evolution, and it is the mode behind most adaptations and most human-driven evolution (pesticide and drug resistance).

Learning objectives

  • Define directional selection
  • Explain the peppered moth case
  • Describe antibiotic resistance as directional selection
  • Predict effects on trait distributions

Shifting the mean

When fitness increases toward one tail, the trait distribution slides: mean beak depth rose in Galapagos finches after droughts favored large-beak seed crackers (Grant's classic data). Alleles for the favored extreme sweep upward; variation narrows as the favored alleles approach fixation.

Mean shifts, variance shrinks

Directional selection moves the bell curve sideways while compressing it.

Peppered moths

Industrial melanism: the carbonaria morph of Biston betularia rose from rare to ~90% near industrial Manchester as soot darkened trees and birds preyed on conspicuous light moths; it fell again after clean-air laws. Kettlewell's mark-recapture experiments (1950s) measured the selective predation directly.

Evolution watched in real time

Rise and fall of melanism with pollution is among the best-documented natural selection cases.

Antibiotic and pesticide resistance

Antibiotics impose brutal directional selection: susceptible bacteria die, resistant mutants (pre-existing or new) survive and multiply. MRSA, multidrug-resistant TB, and herbicide-resistant weeds are directional selection in action, often via single large-effect alleles sweeping fast.

Incomplete treatment selects harder

Sub-lethal dosing kills susceptibles while sparing partial resistants: the perfect recipe for stronger resistance.

Limits and costs

Directional selection depletes the variation it feeds on and often hits trade-offs: large finch beaks crack big seeds but handle small ones poorly. When environments reverse, selection reverses (moth melanism declined post-1956 Clean Air Act).

Selection is reversible

Allele trajectories follow current fitness; yesterday's adaptation can become today's liability.

Key points

  • Directional selection favors one phenotypic extreme, shifting the trait mean
  • Peppered moth melanism tracked industrial pollution both ways
  • Antibiotic resistance is directional selection on microbes
  • It depletes variation and can reverse when environments change

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Directional selection increases variation.

✓ Truth: It reduces it: favored alleles sweep toward fixation, compressing the distribution.

✗ Myth: Peppered moths prove mutations are directed.

✓ Truth: The carbonaria mutation pre-existed; pollution changed SELECTION, not mutation. Selection sorts existing variation.

Practice questions

Q1. Industrial melanism in peppered moths resulted from
  1. New mutations caused by soot
  2. Directional selection favoring dark moths on soot-darkened trees
  3. Drift
  4. Gene flow
Answer: B.

Bird predation selected against conspicuous light moths; the carbonaria allele pre-existed.

Q2. Directional selection typically ___ genetic variation
  1. Increases
  2. Reduces
  3. Does not affect
  4. Doubles
Answer: B.

Favored alleles sweep toward fixation, compressing the trait distribution.

Q3. Incomplete antibiotic courses promote resistance because they
  1. Kill all bacteria
  2. Select for partial resistants while killing susceptibles
  3. Cause mutations directly
  4. Boost immunity
Answer: B.

Sub-lethal exposure is intense directional selection for resistance alleles.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

How fast can directional selection act?

Dramatically: moth melanism shifted in decades; bacterial resistance in years; finch beaks measurably in single droughts.

Why does resistance often involve single genes?

Strong selection favors large-effect alleles that sweep rapidly; polygenic responses are slower and subtler.

What stops directional selection?

Depleted variation, trade-offs (antagonistic pleiotropy), and opposing selection in different environments or life stages.