Intermediatepopulation

The Bottleneck Effect

Overview

A bottleneck occurs when a population's size is drastically reduced (by disease, hunting, habitat loss), so the survivors carry only a fraction of the original genetic variation. Even if numbers later recover, heterozygosity stays low for many generations because drift fixed alleles during the crash. Northern elephant seals, cheetahs, and Mauritius kestrels are textbook cases with direct conservation lessons.

Learning objectives

  • Define a population bottleneck
  • Explain why variation stays low after recovery
  • Give classic examples with numbers
  • Apply bottleneck lessons to conservation

Crash, drift, impoverishment

During a bottleneck of N individuals, heterozygosity drops ~1/(2N) per generation and rare alleles are lost permanently. A one-generation crash to 20 individuals erases ~2.5% of heterozygosity but can eliminate most rare alleles. Recovery in NUMBERS does not restore lost ALLELES: only mutation (slow) or gene flow can.

Numbers recover; alleles do not

A population can rebound to millions yet remain genetically impoverished for millennia.

Northern elephant seals

Hunted to perhaps 20-100 individuals in the 1890s, northern elephant seals now number >200,000 but show extremely low genetic variation: allozyme studies found essentially zero polymorphism. They are the classic demonstration that demographic recovery does not equal genetic recovery.

20 to 200,000

One of history's most dramatic recoveries, yet genetically the species remains a shadow of its former diversity.

Cheetahs and kestrels

Cheetahs suffered ancient bottlenecks (possibly two), leaving them so uniform that unrelated skin grafts are accepted and sperm counts are low. The Mauritius kestrel crashed to 4 known individuals in 1974; intensive management saved it, but inbreeding depression persists.

Inbreeding depression follows

Low variation exposes deleterious recessives: reduced fertility, disease susceptibility, developmental problems.

Conservation applications

Genetic management minimizes kinship in captive breeding (studbooks), maintains Ne above ~50 (short-term) to ~500 (long-term, the 50/500 rule), and uses corridors or translocations for gene flow. The Florida panther's rescue via Texas cougar introductions reversed severe inbreeding depression.

50/500 rule

Ne >= 50 avoids acute inbreeding; Ne >= 500 preserves long-term adaptive potential.

Key points

  • Bottlenecks crash N, drift erases variation, recovery of numbers does not restore alleles
  • Elephant seals: ~20 survivors to 200,000, near-zero variation
  • Cheetahs: ancient bottlenecks, graft acceptance, low fertility
  • Conservation uses the 50/500 rule and managed gene flow

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Once numbers recover, genetic health is restored.

✓ Truth: Lost alleles are gone permanently (barring mutation/gene flow); heterozygosity recovers only over thousands of generations.

✗ Myth: Bottlenecks increase mutation rates.

✓ Truth: They do not create variation; they destroy it. Mutation continues at its normal slow rate throughout.

Practice questions

Q1. A bottleneck reduces genetic variation primarily through
  1. Mutation
  2. Enhanced drift during the crash
  3. Selection
  4. Gene flow
Answer: B.

Tiny N during the crash lets drift fix alleles and erase heterozygosity rapidly.

Q2. Northern elephant seals demonstrate that
  1. Hunting increases variation
  2. Demographic recovery does not restore lost alleles
  3. Bottlenecks are beneficial
  4. Seals are immune to drift
Answer: B.

200,000 seals descend from ~20-100 survivors and remain genetically depauperate.

Q3. The 50/500 rule refers to
  1. Census sizes for delisting
  2. Effective sizes avoiding inbreeding (50) and preserving adaptability (500)
  3. Numbers of founders
  4. Allele counts
Answer: B.

Ne >= 50 short-term, Ne >= 500 long-term conservation targets.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

Why do cheetahs accept unrelated skin grafts?

Near-identical MHC genes from bottleneck-induced uniformity: the immune system sees no foreign tissue.

What is the 50/500 rule?

Ne >= 50 prevents short-term inbreeding depression; Ne >= 500 maintains quantitative genetic variation long-term.

How did Texas cougars save Florida panthers?

Introduced gene flow masked deleterious recessives and restored heterozygosity (genetic rescue).