Advancedspeciation
Sympatric Speciation
Overview
Sympatric speciation — divergence without geographic isolation — was long doubted but is now documented. Mechanisms include disruptive selection with assortative mating (apple maggot flies shifting hosts), and polyploidy (instant speciation in plants). It requires strong selection to overcome gene flow's homogenizing effect.
Learning objectives
- Explain how speciation occurs without barriers
- Describe the apple maggot fly case
- Explain polyploid speciation
Lines of evidence
| Evidence type | Example |
|---|---|
| Field | Rhagoletis host races diverging in real time |
The gene-flow problem
Without barriers, interbreeding homogenizes populations. Sympatric speciation needs disruptive selection strong enough — plus assortative mating — to split one gene pool in two.
Long considered impossible; now accepted as real but uncommon.
Apple maggot flies
Rhagoletis shifted from hawthorn to introduced apples ~200 years ago. Different fruiting times shifted mating times, reducing gene flow; host-race formation is underway — speciation observed.
Polyploidy: instant speciation
Whole-genome duplication (common in plants) creates tetraploids that can't breed with diploid parents — reproductive isolation in one generation. Wheat, cotton, and many wildflowers are polyploid.
Cichlids and crater lakes
African crater-lake cichlids diverged within single small lakes, likely via disruptive selection on feeding ecology — sympatric or micro-allopatric, debated but compelling.
Key points
- Sympatric speciation needs disruptive selection to beat gene flow
- Apple maggot flies show host-shift speciation in action
- Polyploidy creates instant reproductive isolation
- It's real but rarer than allopatric
Common misconceptions
✓ Truth: Documented in flies, fish, and countless polyploid plants.
✓ Truth: It's driven by strong ecological selection.
✓ Truth: It's a major plant speciation mechanism.
Practice questions
Q1. Sympatric speciation occurs:
- Across a mountain range
- Within one geographic area without physical barriers
- Only in labs
- Never
Sympatric speciation is divergence despite shared geography.
Q2. Polyploid speciation is considered instantaneous because:
- It's fast
- Genome duplication immediately creates reproductive isolation
- Plants grow fast
- Mutations are quick
Tetraploid-diploid crosses yield sterile offspring.
Q3. The main obstacle to sympatric speciation is:
- Lack of mutation
- Gene flow homogenizing the diverging populations
- Too much selection
- Small population
Interbreeding erases divergence unless selection is strong.
Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.
Frequently asked questions
How do apple maggot flies show sympatric speciation?
Host shift to apples changed mating timing, cutting gene flow without any geographic barrier.
Why does polyploidy cause instant isolation?
Tetraploid × diploid crosses produce sterile triploids — immediate reproductive barrier.
What overcomes gene flow in sympatry?
Strong disruptive selection plus assortative mating.