Intermediatemechanisms

Sexual Selection

Overview

Sexual selection is selection arising from competition for mates. Darwin proposed it to explain ornaments like peacock tails that seem to hinder survival. It has two modes: intrasexual competition (males fighting for access) and intersexual choice (females preferring certain traits). Elaborate traits evolve when mating advantages outweigh survival costs.

Learning objectives

  • Define the two modes of sexual selection
  • Explain honest signaling and runaway selection
  • Give examples across taxa

Lines of evidence

Evidence typeExample
BehavioralWidowbird tail-length manipulation changing mating success

Competition vs choice

Intrasexual selection: stag antlers, elephant seal bulk — weapons and size for male-male contests. Intersexual selection: bowerbird bowers, peacock trains — traits females prefer.

Darwin's puzzle

Sexual selection explained traits natural selection seemingly couldn't.

Why do females prefer costly traits?

Honest signaling: only healthy males can afford extravagant ornaments (Zahavi's handicap principle). Runaway selection: preference and trait become genetically linked and escalate together (Fisher).

Costs are real

Long tails attract predators; calling frogs attract bats. The trait persists because males with it mate enough to offset the survival cost — a direct fitness trade-off.

Beyond males

Females compete too (jacanas, pipefish), and mutual ornamentation occurs. Sexual selection shapes behavior, color, song, and even sperm.

Key points

  • Sexual selection = competition for mates, via contests or choice
  • Ornaments evolve when mating benefits exceed survival costs
  • Handicap principle and runaway selection explain preferences
  • It operates in both sexes

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Sexual selection opposes natural selection

✓ Truth: It's a component of natural selection — differential reproduction via mating success.

✗ Myth: Only males are ornamented

✓ Truth: Females compete and choose in many species; roles vary.

✗ Myth: Females choose 'the best' rationally

✓ Truth: Preferences evolve; they need not track survival value.

Practice questions

Q1. Peacock tails are best explained by:
  1. Sexual selection via female choice
  2. Random drift
  3. Need for flight
  4. Camouflage
Answer: A.

Females prefer elaborate trains despite survival costs.

Q2. The handicap principle states ornaments are:
  1. Cheap to produce
  2. Honest signals because only quality individuals afford them
  3. Always blue
  4. Learned
Answer: B.

Costliness guarantees honesty because only high-quality individuals can afford the trait.

Q3. Intrasexual selection involves:
  1. Female choice
  2. Competition within one sex for mates
  3. Cooperation
  4. Parental care
Answer: B.

Typically male-male combat for access to females.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

What is the handicap principle?

Costly ornaments honestly signal quality because only fit individuals can afford them.

What is runaway selection?

Fisher's model where female preference and male trait become genetically correlated and escalate together.

Give an intrasexual example.

Stag beetles' mandibles or elephant seal size — weapons for male-male competition.