Intermediatespeciation

Reproductive Isolation

Overview

Reproductive isolation is the set of barriers preventing gene flow between populations. Prezygotic barriers act before fertilization (habitat, timing, behavior, mechanics, gametes); postzygotic barriers act after (hybrid inviability, sterility, breakdown). Isolation usually accumulates gradually as a byproduct of divergence, not as an adaptation to avoid hybridization.

Learning objectives

  • Classify prezygotic vs postzygotic barriers
  • Explain how isolation evolves as a byproduct
  • Describe reinforcement

Lines of evidence

Evidence typeExample
ExperimentalDrosophila mating-preference reinforcement studies

Prezygotic barriers

Habitat isolation (different microhabitats), temporal (different breeding seasons), behavioral (mating rituals), mechanical (incompatible genitalia), gametic (sperm-egg incompatibility). These prevent wasted reproductive effort.

Order

Prezygotic barriers evolve first; they're cheaper.

Postzygotic barriers

Hybrid inviability (embryos fail), hybrid sterility (mules), hybrid breakdown (F2 failures). Dobzhansky-Muller incompatibilities — mismatched gene interactions — underlie most.

Byproduct, not purpose

Isolation typically evolves incidentally as populations diverge, not 'to' prevent hybridization. But reinforcement — selection against hybrids strengthening prezygotic barriers — can complete the process.

Strength varies

Some species pairs are isolated by one strong barrier; others by many weak ones. Barriers are often asymmetric and environment-dependent.

Key points

  • Reproductive isolation = barriers to gene flow
  • Prezygotic acts before fertilization; postzygotic after
  • Isolation usually evolves as a divergence byproduct
  • Reinforcement can strengthen prezygotic barriers

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Species avoid mating deliberately

✓ Truth: Barriers are traits, not intentions.

✗ Myth: One barrier defines species

✓ Truth: Isolation is usually cumulative and leaky.

✗ Myth: Hybrids are always unfit

✓ Truth: Some hybridize successfully; fitness varies.

Practice questions

Q1. Temporal isolation (different breeding seasons) is:
  1. Postzygotic
  2. Prezygotic
  3. Not a barrier
  4. Artificial
Answer: B.

Different breeding seasons block mating itself — it prevents mating, so prezygotic.

Q2. Hybrid sterility, like mules, is an example of:
  1. Prezygotic barrier
  2. Postzygotic barrier
  3. Gene flow
  4. Mutation
Answer: B.

Mule sterility happens despite successful fertilization — it acts after fertilization.

Q3. Reinforcement is selection that:
  1. Weakens barriers
  2. Strengthens prezygotic isolation where hybrids are unfit
  3. Causes extinction
  4. Increases mutation
Answer: B.

Avoiding costly hybridization favors stronger mating barriers.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

What is reinforcement?

Selection strengthening prezygotic barriers where hybrids are unfit, completing speciation.

Why are mules sterile?

Horse-donkey chromosome mismatch disrupts meiosis — postzygotic isolation.

Which barriers evolve first?

Usually prezygotic — they prevent costly wasted mating effort.