Foundationsmechanisms

The Peppered Moth: Industrial Melanism and Natural Selection

Overview

The peppered moth story is the classic demonstration of natural selection: before industrialization, light speckled moths blended with lichen-covered bark; as soot darkened trees near factories, a dark (melanic) variant gained camouflage and spread. When clean-air laws reduced soot, the trend reversed. Modern genetics identified the causative mutation, and refined experiments confirmed bird predation as the selective agent.

Learning objectives

  • Explain the industrial melanism story
  • Evaluate the evidence and later criticisms
  • Describe the genetic basis discovered

Lines of evidence

Evidence typeExample
Field experimentKettlewell's mark-release-recapture predation studies
Geneticcortex-gene transposon insertion identified 2016

The rise of the melanic form

The dark carbonaria form was first recorded near Manchester in 1848. By 1900 it exceeded 90% in industrial areas but stayed rare in rural ones — a tight correlation with soot pollution.

Timeline

Light form dominant pre-1800 → melanic rises with industry → declines after 1960s clean-air legislation.

Kettlewell's experiments — and the controversy

Bernard Kettlewell released marked moths onto trees and recaptured them, finding birds ate the conspicuous form more often. Later critics noted moths don't naturally rest on trunks and that his densities were artificial — but subsequent large-scale experiments with natural resting positions confirmed differential bird predation.

The gene found

In 2016, researchers identified the mutation: a transposable element inserted into the cortex gene drives melanism. The allele swept rapidly — exactly as selection theory predicts for a dominant advantageous variant.

Why textbooks kept it

Few examples show selection's predictions — rise, geographic pattern, and reversal — so cleanly. The criticisms improved the science without overturning the conclusion.

Key points

  • Melanic moths spread with soot pollution and declined with clean air
  • Bird predation on mismatched moths is the selective agent
  • The cortex-gene insertion explains the rapid sweep
  • Criticisms refined but did not refute the case

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: The moth story was faked

✓ Truth: Staged photos were used in textbooks, but the underlying field data and genetics are solid.

✗ Myth: Moths rest on tree trunks

✓ Truth: They usually rest higher on branches; later experiments accounted for this and still found selection.

✗ Myth: One example proves all evolution

✓ Truth: It's one well-documented case among thousands; evolution rests on converging evidence.

Practice questions

Q1. Industrial melanism in peppered moths was driven by:
  1. Birds preferring dark moths as food
  2. Differential camouflage against bird predators
  3. Moths choosing to become dark
  4. Soot mutating all moths
Answer: B.

Conspicuous moths were eaten more; camouflaged ones survived — classic directional selection.

Q2. The reversal of melanism after clean-air legislation shows:
  1. Lamarckism
  2. Selection tracking environmental change
  3. Genetic drift
  4. That moths stopped evolving
Answer: B.

When the environment changed back, so did the direction of selection.

Q3. A valid criticism of early moth experiments was:
  1. Moths don't exist
  2. Release densities and resting positions were unnatural
  3. Birds don't eat moths
  4. Genetics is irrelevant
Answer: B.

Later experiments with natural conditions confirmed the result.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

What caused the melanic form to spread?

Birds ate light moths more often on soot-darkened bark, so dark moths survived and reproduced better.

What happened after clean-air laws?

As bark lightened, the advantage reversed and melanic frequencies fell — selection tracking the environment.

Which gene causes melanism?

An insertion in the cortex gene, identified in 2016.