Intermediatemechanisms

Mass Extinctions

Overview

Five mass extinctions punctuate the fossil record — Ordovician, Devonian, Permian (the worst, ~90% of marine species), Triassic, and Cretaceous (dinosaurs' end). Causes include volcanism, anoxia, and impacts. Each reset ecosystems; survivors radiated into emptied niches. We may now be causing a sixth.

Learning objectives

  • Name the Big Five and their causes
  • Explain extinction selectivity
  • Discuss the sixth-extinction debate

Lines of evidence

Evidence typeExample
GeologicalIridium layer and Chicxulub crater

The Big Five

End-Ordovician (glaciation), Late Devonian (anoxia?), End-Permian (~252 Mya, Siberian volcanism — the 'Great Dying'), End-Triassic (volcanism), End-Cretaceous (66 Mya, Chicxulub impact + Deccan volcanism).

Scale

The Permian event erased ~90% of marine species.

Kill mechanisms

Volcanic CO2 → warming + ocean anoxia + acidification; impacts → darkness, cold, then heat. Selectivity is nonrandom: reef-builders, large bodied, and specialized species die first.

Recovery and radiation

After each, survivors diversify: mammals after dinosaurs, dinosaurs after the Triassic event. Extinction is evolution's great editor — contingency shapes who inherits the Earth.

The sixth?

Current extinction rates are 100-1000× background. Whether it qualifies as 'mass' is debated, but the biodiversity crisis is real and human-caused.

Key points

  • Five mass extinctions reset life's trajectory
  • Volcanism and impacts are the main killers
  • Selectivity favors small generalists
  • Radiations follow extinctions; a sixth may be underway

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Extinctions are random

✓ Truth: Selectivity is strong — specialists and big bodies die first.

✗ Myth: Dinosaurs failed

✓ Truth: They dominated 165 My; contingency, not inferiority, ended them.

✗ Myth: The sixth is certain

✓ Truth: Rates are alarming; 'mass extinction' status is debated.

Practice questions

Q1. The largest mass extinction was the:
  1. Cretaceous
  2. End-Permian
  3. Ordovician
  4. Devonian
Answer: B.

'The Great Dying' erased ~90% of marine species.

Q2. The K-Pg extinction is best explained by:
  1. Volcanoes only
  2. Asteroid impact plus Deccan volcanism
  3. Disease
  4. Ice age
Answer: B.

Iridium layer and Chicxulub crater implicate impact.

Q3. Mass extinctions tend to favor survival of:
  1. Large specialists
  2. Small generalists
  3. Reef builders
  4. Top predators
Answer: B.

Selectivity consistently spares the small and flexible.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

What caused the end-Permian extinction?

Siberian Traps volcanism driving warming, anoxia, and acidification.

What evidence supports the impact theory for the K-Pg?

Global iridium layer, shocked quartz, and the Chicxulub crater.

Why do mammals follow dinosaur extinction?

Emptied niches allowed nocturnal survivors to radiate.