Advancedmechanisms

Kin Selection and Altruism

Overview

Kin selection explains altruism — behavior that costs the actor but benefits others — through inclusive fitness: genes spread by helping relatives who share them. Hamilton's rule (rB > C) predicts altruism evolves when the benefit to the recipient, weighted by relatedness, exceeds the cost. Haplodiploidy in ants, bees, and wasps (sisters share 75% of genes) famously favors worker altruism.

Learning objectives

  • State Hamilton's rule and apply it
  • Explain haplodiploidy and eusociality
  • Evaluate evidence and controversies

Lines of evidence

Evidence typeExample
BehavioralAlarm-call patterns in Belding's ground squirrels

Hamilton's rule

Altruism spreads when rB > C: relatedness × benefit to recipient > cost to actor. A gene for helping siblings (r = 0.5) spreads if it saves more than two sibling-equivalents per sacrifice.

Formula

rB > C — relatedness times benefit must exceed cost.

Haplodiploidy

In ants/bees/wasps, males are haploid: daughters get identical paternal genes, so sisters share 75%. Workers thus propagate more genes by raising sisters than by having daughters (50%) — favoring sterile castes.

Alarm calls and helpers

Belding's ground squirrels call to warn relatives despite attracting predators; callers are typically females near kin. Florida scrub jays help raise siblings before breeding themselves.

Debates

Critics note eusociality also occurs in diploids (termites, naked mole rats) and emphasize ecological factors. Kin selection remains the leading framework but not the whole story.

Key points

  • Altruism can evolve via benefits to shared genes in relatives
  • Hamilton's rule: rB > C
  • Haplodiploidy predisposes Hymenoptera to eusociality
  • Ecology also matters — kinship isn't everything

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Altruism disproves evolution

✓ Truth: Kin selection shows self-sacrifice can be genetically selfish.

✗ Myth: Animals calculate relatedness

✓ Truth: They use cues like nest-mate odor; the math describes outcomes, not cognition.

✗ Myth: Only insects show kin-selected altruism

✓ Truth: Alarm calls, cooperative breeding, and food sharing occur widely.

Practice questions

Q1. Hamilton's rule predicts altruism when:
  1. rB > C
  2. B > rC
  3. C > rB
  4. r = 1
Answer: A.

Relatedness-weighted benefit must exceed the actor's cost.

Q2. Haplodiploid sisters share what fraction of genes?
  1. 25%
  2. 50%
  3. 75%
  4. 100%
Answer: C.

Identical paternal genome makes full sisters 75% related.

Q3. Belding's ground squirrel alarm calls support kin selection because:
  1. Callers are usually females living near relatives
  2. Males call most
  3. Calls attract mates
  4. Predators ignore them
Answer: A.

Callers risk themselves to warn kin — rB > C in action.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

What is inclusive fitness?

An individual's own reproductive success plus effects on relatives' reproduction, weighted by relatedness.

Why are worker ants sterile?

In haplodiploid colonies, raising sisters (75% related) beats having daughters (50%) — Hamilton's rule favors it.

Do diploid eusocial species exist?

Yes — termites and naked mole rats, showing ecology complements kinship.