Intermediatemechanisms

Directional Selection in Detail

Overview

Directional selection occurs when one extreme of a trait distribution has consistently higher fitness, moving the population mean over generations. It drives adaptation to new conditions: darker moths in soot, resistant pests under pesticides, larger finch beaks in drought. At the genetic level, favored alleles sweep toward fixation, leaving signatures like reduced diversity around the selected locus.

Learning objectives

  • Explain the genetic basis of directional shifts
  • Describe selective sweeps
  • Give molecular and field examples

Lines of evidence

Evidence typeExample
GenomicSweep signatures at lactase and EDAR loci in humans

From phenotype to allele sweep

When an allele confers an advantage, its frequency rises logistically. Linked neutral variants hitchhike along, creating a selective sweep — a valley of reduced diversity around the gene that genomicists use to find past selection.

Detection

Genome scans for sweep signatures revealed selection on lactase, skin pigmentation, and high-altitude genes in humans.

Classic field cases

Peppered moth melanism, insecticide resistance, heavy-metal tolerance in grasses on mine tailings, and beak size in Galapagos finches all show directional shifts tracked in real time.

Limits and reversals

Directional selection stops when alleles fix, variation runs out, or trade-offs bite. When environments reverse — clean air laws and moth color — selection reverses too.

Artificial directional selection

Crop and livestock breeding is deliberate directional selection: corn oil content, dog size, racehorse speed. Response follows the breeder's equation R = h²S.

Key points

  • Directional selection shifts trait means toward the favored extreme
  • Favored alleles sweep, dragging linked variants (hitchhiking)
  • It halts at fixation, exhaustion of variation, or trade-offs
  • The breeder's equation predicts response

Common misconceptions

✗ Myth: Directional selection never stops

✓ Truth: It stops when variation is exhausted or costs outweigh benefits.

✗ Myth: Sweeps erase all diversity

✓ Truth: They reduce diversity near the locus; distant regions are unaffected.

✗ Myth: It's always caused by humans

✓ Truth: Natural environmental change drives it constantly.

Practice questions

Q1. A selective sweep is detected as:
  1. Increased diversity everywhere
  2. Reduced genetic diversity around a favored locus
  3. More mutations
  4. Larger populations
Answer: B.

Hitchhiking linked variants creates a diversity valley.

Q2. In R = h²S, h² represents:
  1. Height
  2. Heritability
  3. Happiness
  4. Homozygosity
Answer: B.

Narrow-sense heritability scales the response to selection.

Q3. Directional selection on finch beaks during drought favored:
  1. Small beaks
  2. Large, deep beaks for hard seeds
  3. No change
  4. Thinner beaks
Answer: B.

Birds that could crack hard Tribulus seeds survived.

Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.

Frequently asked questions

What is a selective sweep?

The rapid rise of a beneficial allele, carrying linked neutral variants with it and reducing local genetic diversity.

What is the breeder's equation?

R = h²S: response equals heritability times the selection differential — predicting evolutionary change.

Can directional selection reverse?

Yes — peppered moths show selection flipping direction as pollution came and went.