Foundationspopulations
Survivorship Curves: Type I, II, and III
Overview
A survivorship curve graphs lx - the proportion of a cohort still alive - against age, compressing a life table's survival column into a single picture. Ecologists recognize three classic shapes: Type I (low early mortality, most die of old age), Type II (constant mortality at all ages), and Type III (massive early mortality, few survivors live long). This lesson teaches each type, the species that exemplify them, how the curves connect to life-history strategy, and the log-scale trick that makes them readable.
Learning objectives
- Define a survivorship curve and explain what its axes show.
- Describe Type I, II, and III curves and give an example species for each.
- Explain why the y-axis is usually logarithmic.
- Relate curve shape to life-history strategy and parental care.
Humans: 95% survive to age 50 (Type I). Songbirds: roughly constant 50% annual survival at every age (Type II). Oysters: 10 million larvae, ~100 adults (Type III).
Interpretation: The same lx plot tells three different life stories: invest in few and protect them, accept steady attrition, or play the numbers game. Curve shape directly reflects the parental-investment versus fecundity trade-off.
What the curve shows
A survivorship curve plots lx, the fraction of the original cohort surviving, on the y-axis against age on the x-axis. It always starts at 1.0 (everyone alive at birth) and falls toward zero as the cohort dies out. The shape reveals when mortality strikes: a steep early drop means most die young, a late drop means most survive to old age. Because lx spans orders of magnitude - from 1.0 down to 0.0001 in high-mortality species - the y-axis is plotted on a logarithmic scale, which turns constant proportional mortality into a straight line.
On a log y-axis, a constant death rate plots as a straight diagonal line. Curves that bow above or below the diagonal reveal ages of unusually low or high mortality.
Type I: survive, then senesce
Type I curves stay near 1.0 through most of life and plunge only at old age - mortality is concentrated in the elderly. Humans in developed countries, elephants, and other large mammals with heavy parental investment show this pattern. It pairs with K-selected life histories: few offspring, each given enormous care, so early survival is high. On a log plot, the Type I curve bows upward (convex), staying high before its late drop.
Type II: constant risk
Type II curves are straight diagonal lines on a log plot - the chance of dying is roughly the same at every age. Many birds, some lizards, and perennial plants approximate this pattern: once past the vulnerable juvenile stage, a 2-year-old and a 10-year-old face similar odds. Type II species sit between the extremes of parental care, producing moderate numbers of offspring with moderate investment. Perfect Type II curves are rare because mortality usually varies somewhat with age, but the straight-line ideal is a useful reference.
Type III: the great culling
Type III curves crash steeply at the start and then flatten - enormous early mortality followed by low mortality for the lucky survivors. Oysters releasing millions of larvae, most fish, many insects, and plants scattering thousands of seeds all show this pattern. It pairs with r-selected life histories: huge numbers of tiny offspring with no parental care, where survival is a lottery. On a log plot the curve bows downward (concave), dropping fast then leveling.
Curves, strategies, and caveats
Curve type correlates with life-history strategy because both reflect the same trade-off: invest heavily in few offspring (Type I) or scatter many cheap offspring (Type III). But real curves are messier than the three ideals - many species show Type III early mortality followed by Type I-like adult survival (sea turtles are a famous hybrid), and human curves shifted from Type II-ish to Type I as medicine cut child mortality. The three types are reference shapes for thinking, not rigid boxes every species must fit.
Key points
- Survivorship curves plot lx (proportion surviving) versus age, usually with a logarithmic y-axis.
- Type I: low early mortality, die-off in old age (humans, elephants) - pairs with heavy parental care.
- Type II: constant mortality at all ages, a straight diagonal on a log plot (many birds).
- Type III: massive early mortality, low later mortality (oysters, most fish, many plants) - pairs with huge fecundity and no care.
- Real species often blend types, and human curves have shifted historically as child mortality fell.
Common misconceptions
✓ Truth: The strategy works: producing millions of offspring with a tiny survival fraction still yields enough survivors. Success is measured by R0, not by individual survival odds.
✓ Truth: Before modern medicine, high child mortality gave human curves a much steeper early drop. The strongly Type I shape is a recent product of sanitation, vaccines, and nutrition.
✓ Truth: The types are idealized reference shapes; many species show mixed curves, such as Type III juvenile mortality with Type I adult survival.
Practice questions
Q1. A researcher plots lx on a log scale and gets a nearly straight diagonal line from birth to old age. Which type is this?
- Type I
- Type II
- Type III
- Type IV
A straight diagonal on a log plot means a constant proportional death rate at all ages - the definition of a Type II survivorship curve. Type I would bow upward (convex) and Type III would drop steeply then flatten (concave).
Q2. An oyster releases 10 million eggs; about 100 survive to adulthood. Which curve and strategy does this exemplify?
- Type I with K-selection
- Type II with intermediate strategy
- Type III with r-selection
- Type I with r-selection
Massive early mortality with a few long-lived survivors is the Type III curve, produced by the r-selected strategy of enormous fecundity with no parental care. The 100 survivors are enough because the starting number was so huge.
Q3. Why did human survivorship curves become more Type I-like over the last century?
- Humans started having more children
- Child mortality fell sharply due to medicine, sanitation, and nutrition
- Adult mortality increased
- The y-axis scale changed
Historically, high infant and child mortality gave human curves a steep early drop. Sanitation, vaccines, antibiotics, and better nutrition slashed early deaths, so most people now survive to old age - the Type I pattern of late-life mortality.
Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the y-axis logarithmic on survivorship curves?
Because survival fractions span orders of magnitude - a Type III species may go from 1.0 to 0.00001. A log scale makes the whole curve visible and turns constant proportional mortality into a straight line, so deviations from straight reveal ages of unusual mortality.
Which curve type goes with r-selected species?
Type III. r-selected species produce huge numbers of offspring with minimal investment, so most die young - exactly the steep early drop of the Type III curve. K-selected species with heavy parental care show Type I.
Do plants have survivorship curves?
Yes. Most plants show Type III curves - a tree may produce millions of seeds of which a handful become adults. Some long-lived perennials with good establishment approximate Type I or II once past the seedling stage.
What does a steeper curve mean?
Steeper means faster mortality at those ages. A curve that drops steeply early (Type III) means most individuals die young; one that stays flat then drops late (Type I) means most survive until old age.