Foundationscommunities
Species Richness vs Evenness
Overview
Species richness and species evenness are the two independent axes of diversity, and confusing them is one of ecology's most common errors. Richness is simply the count of species; evenness is how equitably individuals (or biomass) are distributed among them. This lesson contrasts the two with worked examples, introduces rank-abundance curves that display both at a glance, and explains why conservation decisions need both numbers - protecting richness without evenness can mean protecting a species list dominated by a single aggressive invader.
Learning objectives
- Define species richness and species evenness precisely.
- Explain why two communities with equal richness can differ greatly in diversity.
- Read and interpret a rank-abundance curve.
- Argue why conservation targets need both richness and evenness.
Both meadows: 20 species. Meadow A: each ~5% cover (J = 0.98). Meadow B: one species at 85% cover, 19 species sharing 15% (J = 0.42).
Interpretation: Same richness, opposite communities. A's near-perfect evenness means resilient, shared function; B is functionally a near-monoculture vulnerable to whatever hits its dominant. Richness alone would call them equals - evenness reveals the truth.
Richness: the simple count
Species richness (S) is the number of species in a community - the simplest diversity measure and the easiest to grasp. Count the bird species in a forest plot, the fish species in a reef transect, the plant species in a quadrat: that is richness. It responds to area (bigger areas hold more species - the species-area relationship), to habitat heterogeneity, and to latitude. But richness is blind to abundance: a species represented by one struggling individual counts exactly as much as one represented by ten thousand thriving ones.
A richness of 50 sounds impressive until you learn one species holds 99% of individuals. Always ask about evenness before celebrating a species count.
Evenness: the balance
Species evenness measures how equitably individuals are distributed among the species present. Maximum evenness means every species has the same abundance; minimum evenness means one species dominates completely. Evenness is often expressed as a ratio, such as Pielou's J = H / ln(S), which scales the Shannon index against its maximum for that richness. Evenness captures ecological reality that richness misses: dominance hierarchies, competitive exclusion in progress, and the functional difference between a balanced meadow and a weed-choked lot with the same species list.
Rank-abundance curves: seeing both at once
A rank-abundance (Whittaker) plot displays richness and evenness simultaneously: species ranked from most to least abundant on the x-axis, log abundance on the y-axis. Richness is the curve's length (how far it extends right); evenness is its slope (a shallow slope means even, a steep plunge means dominated). Ecologists fit these curves to models - geometric series (harsh, dominance-heavy communities), log series, lognormal (typical mature communities), and broken-stick (very even) - each implying different assembly processes.
What drives each component
Richness and evenness respond to different forces. Richness rises with area, habitat complexity, evolutionary time, and immigration, and falls with extinction and harsh filters. Evenness falls when a strong competitor, predator release, or nutrient pulse lets one species dominate, and rises when disturbances, predators, or pathogens keep dominants in check - the mechanism behind Paine's starfish result. Because their drivers differ, the two components can move independently: eutrophication often leaves richness temporarily intact while evenness collapses as algae take over.
Why conservation needs both
A reserve managed for richness alone can fail badly. Consider a grassland where richness stays at 40 species but an invasive grass climbs from 10% to 90% of biomass: richness reports 'no change' while the community's function, fire regime, and wildlife value transform. Monitoring evenness catches dominance shifts early, before rare species are actually lost. Restoration targets likewise specify both - not just 'plant 30 native species' but 'establish them at abundances resembling reference sites.' Diversity is two-dimensional, and management must be too.
Key points
- Richness (S) counts species; evenness measures how equitably individuals are distributed among them.
- Two communities with identical richness can have radically different diversity if their evenness differs.
- Rank-abundance curves show richness as curve length and evenness as slope on a single plot.
- Richness responds to area, heterogeneity, and time; evenness responds to dominance, disturbance, and top-down control.
- Conservation monitoring needs both: richness can stay flat while evenness collapses under invasion or eutrophication.
Common misconceptions
✓ Truth: Diversity can collapse through evenness loss alone - when one species comes to dominate, the community's effective diversity falls even with zero extinctions.
✓ Truth: They are independent axes: richness can rise while evenness falls (adding rare species to a dominated community) or vice versa. One cannot be derived from the other.
✓ Truth: Steepness shows low evenness (dominance), not low richness - a steep curve can extend far to the right, indicating many species with one overwhelming dominant.
Practice questions
Q1. Two meadows each have 20 plant species. In meadow A each species covers ~5% of ground; in meadow B one species covers 85%. Which statement is correct?
- They have equal diversity
- Meadow A has higher evenness and higher overall diversity
- Meadow B has higher evenness
- Richness cannot be compared
Richness is equal (20 species each), but A is far more even while B is dominated by one species. Since diversity combines both components, A's high evenness gives it substantially higher diversity despite identical richness.
Q2. On a rank-abundance plot, what does a very steep initial drop indicate?
- High species richness
- Low evenness - strong dominance by the top-ranked species
- High evenness
- Sampling error
Steepness is the evenness axis: a sharp plunge means abundance falls off rapidly from the dominant species to the rest - low evenness. Curve length (rightward extent) would indicate richness.
Q3. A lake's fish richness stays at 12 species for a decade, but an invasive carp rises from 5% to 80% of biomass. What happened to diversity?
- Nothing - richness is unchanged so diversity is unchanged
- Diversity fell because evenness collapsed
- Diversity rose because carp is a new species
- Richness increased
This is evenness collapse without extinction: the species list is identical but the abundance distribution is now dominated by one species. Every diversity index (Shannon, Simpson) would fall sharply - the classic case for monitoring evenness, not just richness.
Click a question to reveal the answer and explanation.
Frequently asked questions
What is Pielou's evenness index?
Pielou's J = H / ln(S) scales the observed Shannon diversity against the maximum possible for that richness. J = 1 means perfect evenness; J near 0 means extreme dominance. It isolates the evenness component so communities with different richness can be compared fairly.
Why is the y-axis logarithmic on rank-abundance plots?
Abundances typically span orders of magnitude - the top species may have 10,000 individuals and the rarest just 1. A log scale keeps the whole community visible and makes the classic curve shapes (geometric, lognormal) recognizable.
Can evenness increase while richness decreases?
Yes. If a dominant species declines, the remaining species become more equitable even as total species count falls - for example, when a disease removes a dominant tree, the survivors share the canopy more evenly. The two components move independently.
Which matters more for ecosystem function, richness or evenness?
It depends on the function, but evenness often matters more for stability: a community where function is spread across many co-dominant species keeps working when one falters, while a dominated community lives or dies with its dominant. Both are routinely measured because each predicts different things.